If you have passed by a newsstand recently, you probably saw this headline article in the latest Atlantic Monthly. What?! Christianity to blame? What does that even mean? I needed to read this article. The fact is that the title is a bit misleading. The real culprit is not Christianity as a whole, but rather one group claiming to be “Christian”—prosperity gospel preachers. In my opinion, not the best idea of what Christianity actually is.
So what is the real issue? Prosperity gospel preachers encouraged people who could not afford housing to get their own home and to “Go big”. In some cases, the preachers stated it was sin to have financial failure, so the teaching was that you expect God to work. In other words we should all go beyond our current means and expect God to take care of the rest. Dangerous!
Think I am being too unfair? Here is a case-in-point. The author quotes a woman in one of these congregations;
“If you have financial pressure on you, and you don’t know where the next payment is coming from, don’t pay any attention to that!” “Don’t get discouraged! Jesus is the answer.”
Jesus is the answer, but not like this. In the example above Jesus will magically appear with money for you to pay your next bill. I agree Jesus can provide in miraculous ways. He has done it before. But the quote above seems to go beyond asking God to intervene. It sounds more like Satan’s use of Scripture in the temptation of Jesus. Satan tempts Jesus to be reckless, to be bold and step out. “God won’t let you fail! He will protect you.” Satan wanted Jesus to step off the pinnacle of the temple and have God save Him. Jesus saw through that and so should you. This is testing God. The woman in the article said “…don’t pay any attention to that!” We certainly should pay attention to that. God cares for us usually by providing for our needs through normal methods—thoughtfulness and planning. These methods are no less miraculous since He gives us everything that we have. Jesus is the answer. He really is! With Him I don’t need a bigger house to feel blessed by God or to be worth anything. He loves us and that is enough. He is enough.
To the author’s credit, it is acknowledged that not all Christians would agree with these preachers. Rick Warren, of The Purpose Driven Life fame, is quoted saying the idea that faithful Christians will prosper financially is baloney and “You don’t measure your self-worth by your net worth.” Wonderful and true, as far as it goes.
The article was well written and raised some good issues, though I cannot agree with the conclusions. The author was fair and seemed to let the people involved do the talking, hanging themselves with their own words. As a follower of Jesus and someone who loves Him, the statements of the prosperity preachers bothered me most.
The author did throw in her two cents worth near the end. “Much of popular religion these days is characterized by a vast gap between aspirations and reality. Few of Sarah Palin’s religious compatriots were shocked by her messy family life, because they’ve grown used to paradoxes; some of the most socially conservative evangelical churches also have extremely high rates of teenage pregnancies, out-of-wedlock births, and divorce.” The assumption: Christians don’t live what they preach. Unfortunately this is true, but the story does not end there. While the quote is true, it makes two mistakes. First, it assumes we should be without sin. It assumes Christians are better than others. We are not. We need Jesus too. The gospel reminds us that even on our best days, we still fall short of righteousness. Second, it assumes that everyone claiming Christianity actually is a Christian. Also false since claiming Christ and being in love with Christ are radically different.
So what do we do with the prosperity gospel preachers? I was appalled at the end of the article. The main pastor who was the focus of the piece is asked about how you will know if God is telling you to buy a home. He says,
“Ten Christians will say that God told them to buy a house. In nine of the cases, it will go bad. The 10th one is the real Christian.” The author asks about the other nine. “For them, there’s always another house.”
So for the real Christian, everything worked fine? Horrifying! If something does not go right for you, you just don’t have enough faith? If you suffer, God is not pleased? There is nothing more anti-gospel than that concept. Think about how many people in Scripture suffer. Ironic that we are guaranteed suffering if we are a believer and in one place it is even stated that suffering was granted to us for Jesus’ sake. (Philippians 1:29) How is that for prosperity?